Sofia Pizza Shoppe is a New York-style pizzeria with a modern twist on First Avenue in the Sutton Place area.
Reviewers call it a local favorite with well-baked crust and balanced toppings; the pepperoni slice with caramelized onions and honey and the seasonal grandma slice stand out. It offers delivery and pickup.
Venue Map data © OpenStreetMap contributors · Leaflet
Starter listings from public sources — verify hours before visiting. Listed Nov 13, 2026. Map data © OpenStreetMap contributors (ODbL). Owner or regular? Send a correction.