The Astarita is a pizzeria on Fifth Avenue in Sunset Park.
Reviewers praise the kind, hardworking staff and authentic food: calzones, classic New York pizza, homemade meatballs and a Nutella pizza for dessert.
In the news & reviews
- Restaurantji review of The Astarita
“It’s a small and mighty place for pizza and pasta.”
- Restaurantji review of The Astarita
“The best eggplant parm/eggplant rollatini ever.”
Venue Map data © OpenStreetMap contributors · Leaflet
Starter listings from public sources — verify hours before visiting. Listed Nov 13, 2026. Map data © OpenStreetMap contributors (ODbL). Owner or regular? Send a correction.