Restaurant American Seafood Top Rated American, Seafood Pelham Bay / Country Club / City Island

304 City Island Avenue, Bronx, NY 10464
+1 718 885 9559

City Island Diner is a classic diner on City Island Avenue.

Reviewers call it a beloved local spot for breakfast and lunch; corned beef hash and eggs, pastrami on rye, fried calamari and buttermilk pancakes are favorites.

Ratings from across the web

Restaurantji4.5185 ratings

Ratings as of Nov 2026. Figures change; follow the links for current numbers.

In the news & reviews

Restaurantji review of City Island Diner
Restaurantji (customer review)
“Joe and Brunie recommend City Island Diner.”

More in Pelham Bay / Country Club / City Island

Clipper Coffee · City Island Lobster House · Johnny’s Reef Restaurant · George’s Restaurant · Golden Chef (Healthy Food) · Man Overboard · All 7 →

Starter listings from public sources — verify hours before visiting. Listed Nov 13, 2026. Map data © OpenStreetMap contributors (ODbL). Owner or regular? Send a correction.