Johnny’s Reef is a family-friendly seafood spot at the southern tip of City Island, a favorite for more than 50 years.
Reviewers praise the scenic setting, fresh fried seafood and decent prices; shrimp baskets with calamari, steamed lobster tails and piña coladas are favorites.
In the news & reviews
- Restaurantji review of Johnny's Reef Restaurant
“I've been visiting Johnny's for over 30+years.”
Venue Map data © OpenStreetMap contributors · Leaflet
More in Pelham Bay / Country Club / City Island
Clipper Coffee · City Island Lobster House · City Island Diner · George’s Restaurant · Golden Chef (Healthy Food) · Man Overboard · All 7 →
Starter listings from public sources — verify hours before visiting. Listed Nov 13, 2026. Map data © OpenStreetMap contributors (ODbL). Owner or regular? Send a correction.